No - end of strawman. Once again, you divert attention from the subject at hand, which was the contents of video. No references, no supporting information - no credibility for the content.CKinnard wrote:Unbridled emotionalism.RhapsodyX wrote:To save people wasting their time - IMHO, it is a waste of time. A naturopath using youtube as a vehicle for their preferred view of the world, using an N=65 study as "proof" that a "calorie density" view of dieting was better than "high fat" (which version would that be?).
No better than hearsay. A waste of 10 minutes and 47 seconds of my life.
The debate over which diet sates best is no doubt confounded by the dietary preferences of the study subjects. Presumably, those with a preference and history of SAD may be happier with hamburgers, cheese from a bottle, and ice cream.
Consider that plant based whole food eaters have healthier BMIs and greater longevity.
What does this tell us about satiety?
- To keep one's BMI within healthy limits long term is obviously dependent on satiety on a eucaloric diet.
- Therefore, it logically follows PBWF eaters are sated before overfeeding. Therefore, satiation advantage rests with the PBWF, as does longevity and low morbidity advantage.
END OF ARGUMENT
_______________________________
Lifted straight from her bio pages. Which University awarded the PhD? An online university, wasn't it? Run-ins with the Ohio authorities regarding giving dietary advice? Yes, highly qualified and regarded.CKinnard wrote: Pam Popper has earned a PhD and is highly regarded and employed by the US govt and many large private corporations. She is more qualified to give dietary advice than a medical physician. I've watched many of her presentations, and not one is out of line with the bulk of literature that shows the longevity advantage lies with PBWF, or that PBWF can reverse atherosclerosis.
Rhapsody, read the literature more broadly before giving others' advice about what is a waste of time.
As for "Broad", I do believe the narrow view is from the other side of the fence. I, at least, have an open mind.